Mar 26, 2011

... and here's the resolution itself

Resolution : End the Wars, Redirect Resources to Critical Needs
March 14, 2011 Lewisboro Town Board

Whereas, March 19, 2011 is the 8th anniversary of the U.S. invasion of Iraq, and October will be the 10th anniversary of the Afghanistan war, arguably the longest in U.S. history, and

Whereas, our country and community face the most severe economic crisis since the Great Depression; and

Whereas, 58 cents of every tax dollar spent by the Federal Government on discretionary appropriations is spent to pay for past, present and future military expenditures;

Whereas, not including U.S. military forces presently serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, our country maintains more than 350,000 troops stationed in 146 countries and a network of more than 800 bases in 63 foreign countries, which together cost more than $372 billion annually; and

Whereas, U.S. military spending is nearly equal to the total military spending of the rest of the world, and interest payments alone on the military portion of the national debt consumed $30.25 billion in 2009; and

Whereas, between FY 2001 and FY 2008, federal grants to state and local governments increased 0.57% for every 1% increase in total federal budget authority; yet, during the same period, federal military expenditures increased 1.47% for every 1% in total federal budget authority - 258 times the rate of increase in grants to state and local government; and

Whereas, for every $1 billion spent on the military 11,600 jobs are created, while for the same billion dollars 14,800 jobs are created in consumption derived from tax cuts; 17,100 jobs are created by investments in clean energy; 19,600 jobs are created by funding health care; and 29,100 jobs are created from spending on education; and

Whereas, the Pentagon budget was $297 billion when President Clinton left office, and the proposed 2011 fiscal year Pentagon budget was $708 billion, more than double, and military spending by other agencies raises that total to more than $1 trillion; and

Whereas, instead of making us safer, this massive misallocation of resources and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have created more enemies and actually increased the risk of terrorism, and have already cost the lives of over 5000 U.S. troops, wounding more than 100,000 others, and when future medical treatment for injured veterans, replacement equipment and armament, interest payments on the military portion of the debt, and other residual costs are factored in, by 2017 total expenditures are projected to run between $3 and $5 trillion; and

Whereas, this drain on the public treasury is bleeding our nation and forcing a choice between ever greater debt that will be borne by future generations or severe cuts in vital social programs and public services, resulting in government’s inability to meet the most basic needs of our people; and

Whereas, there is no military solution to the problem of terrorism, but terrorists have been effectively dealt with as a criminal justice problem, using police and intelligence methods, choking off finances, and through development assistance, education and other means to address the underlying grievances that are a seedbed for terrorism;
therefore,

Be it resolved, that the Town Board of the Town of Lewisboro calls upon the Congress and the President to change course by ending the wasteful and unwinnable wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, dismantling the global network of military bases, bringing all our troops and tax dollars home, and dramatically shifting our national priorities to meet human needs, restore vital social programs and public services, rebuild our nation’s deteriorating infrastructure, decaying inner cities and the still devastated Gulf Coast, thereby creating stable jobs at living wages for all who seek employment, and by putting our nation on an environmentally sustainable, ecologically responsible path that addresses the challenge of global warming and environmental degradation while reinvigorating our economy; and

Be it finally resolved, that our nation’s security can be more effectively enhanced by using our resources to address the causes of global poverty, hunger, disease, and under-development that are the seedbed for conflict, and by relying on diplomacy, development aid, and international cooperation rather than force of arms, war and military occupation to protect our national security and promote peaceful relations with other countries and peoples.

Ledger: Welsh’s resolution: Raised and rejected

Town Board members quickly shot down a resolution to “End the Wars, Redirect Resources to Critical Needs” presented by Town Board member Dan Welsh at the March 14 meeting.

The proposed resolution describes in detail the enormous financial toll taken by the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and asks that the Town Board “call upon Congress and the President to change course by ending the wasteful and unwinnable wars … dismantling the global network of military bases, bringing all of our troops and tax dollars home, and dramatically shifting our national priorities to meet human needs.”

The resolution states that our nation’s security may be more effectively enhanced by using our resources to address the causes of global poverty, hunger disease and underdevelopment that are the seedbed for conflict.

Although the resolution was lengthy, Town Board members took only a minute to shoot it down.

“This is one of the most infantile and puerile things I have ever heard,” said Town Board member Frank Kelly, a decorated veteran of the war in Iraq.

Town Board member Peter DeLucia agreed. “The reason we have the freedom to sit here tonight and listen to this is because of our great armed forces. There is no way I would ever even consider seconding a motion on this.”

Supervisor Duffy said he was in agreement with his two colleagues. There was no rebuttal from Mr. Welsh.

Oct 2, 2010

Guest Column Re Budget Deliberations

When you hear "somebody's got to be willing to make the tough decisions", you know the politics is getting revved up.

Guest column: Time to fix budget

A Town Board member’s vote on a budget is a matter of judgment. Where would the majority of residents come out on it? Are the compromises palatable? Is there something “good” which trumps something “popular”? When the majority of the Town Board voted to submit the “austerity budget” to public hearing last week, they apparently found that tax relief outweighed all other considerations. I (and Bruce Pavalow, though I do not purport to represent him here) found otherwise.

The price for achieving the proper “visuals” on this budget includes, among other things, the slashing of an already thin workforce, and cutting of essential services. I saw impacts to our fundamental obligations towards the safety of our residents, and the human reality of long-term dedicated employees and recognition of their status as important stakeholders in the process as tipping the balance against the drastic cuts. I also have strong reservations about the continued masking of financial deficits with temporary plugs.

I think there may be some difference in perception about what actually was sitting on the other side of the balance. My colleagues saw it as an increase that “we just can’t ask of the taxpayer after all they’ve been through.” Whether it’s 6.7% (the original tentative budget), or four-point-something that would have been the figure if we had restored some of the above-mentioned real people to the roles, it was just too much to ask of them. Maybe it’s hard to ask, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not the right thing to do. In absolute terms, those items may cost the average taxpayer roughly $60 a year. Non-wealthy folks that I know have made it clear that they would prefer a modest increase to service cuts that typically hit the average working stiff harder than someone better off.

My colleagues did not characterize it this way, but there are critics out there who want to draw parallels between our town workforce and the “bloated government” archetype as one might find described in a New York Post article on the MTA. Having lived through last year’s seven-month long budget process and the cuts that were made then, I can say that our small town government, made even smaller thereby, just does not harbor a lot of places where anything like bloat can lurk. That does not mean we don’t want to constantly be looking for ways to be more efficient, but we certainly are at the point where we should be trading in our budget machetes for budget paring knives. I feel this last session was one whack too many with the machete.
Perhaps most importantly of all, in placing a flat budget above all other concerns, my colleagues are not making adequate progress in eliminating the budgetary misdirection that is at the root of our financial troubles. There is about $430,000 of “Levy Money” (proceeds from the sale of the parcel left to the town in the deal establishing the preserve) being used to compensate for an operating deficit of the same size in this budget. The $75,000 reserve allowance cuts that deficit back to, call it $350,000. This is only marginally less than the operating deficit in the 2010 year. This means we are passing this problem largely on to the future to resolve. Unsustainable staff cuts are also a form of deferral. Eventually, we are going to have to staff to do the job, and at that time, we will have to pay for it. In my mind, we should at least be cutting this operating deficit in half, to $200,000. That means another $50 to $60 a household. In total, perhaps $150 from each taxpayer will restore services and move us towards fiscal stability. Put that in your scale and let the Town Board know which way it tilts. There is still time to fix things before the final vote.

Mr. Welsh is a Town Board member.

Feb 27, 2010

Clean Energy Finance for Lewisboro

Thankfully, and maybe with the help of measured, non-ideological commentary like this from the Ledger, the Town Board voted to participate in this Northern Westchester Energy Acton Consortium program. It will take a while to develop, but I'm glad that Lewisboro chose to stay on the curve rather than behind it.

Editorial: Keeping the PACE

Dan Welsh may soon lose his position as part of the majority party on the Town Board, but he has not lost his zeal for energy-saving initiatives. His latest proposal, to have Lewisboro join Bedford and other municipalities to qualify for state money to enable homeowners to retrofit their homes with energy upgrades, appears to be another “smart” idea the board needs to seriously consider.

New York’s PACE program — Property Assessed Clean Energy — eliminates the upfront costs for energy improvements by allowing taxpayers to pay for them over 15 to 20 years through an increase in their annual property taxes. More information regarding the proposal is needed, but the concept is sound and does not appear to burden the town in any way. Instead, it would merely serve as a medium for the state to deliver the money to residents who want to make the upgrades but lack the money to pay for them entirely now, and for the financing to be repaid. Makes sense, right? Well, so did the proposal to consider Smart Grid technology, with no commitment by the town. The outcome? The Town Board was the only one of 13 local municipality governing bodies to turn it down.

What makes this proposal’s standing in Lewisboro even more precarious is that some board members stated that the totality of their efforts must be focused on eliminating the deficit at the expense of other projects. The board has rightfully spent countless hours attacking the deficit and will continue to do so for months, but that doesn’t mean that all else be ignored, especially projects at no cost that save energy and lower residents’ utility bills.

Climategate may finally quiet those who were screaming that global warming is solely a manmade phenomenon that is occurring at an alarming pace, but that does not mean that the environment should be tread upon harshly. Instead, conservation efforts and green initiatives, such as this one, that come without burdening property owners deserve support by local governments to help ensure the environment remains protected for years to come.

Oct 1, 2009

Oct 1, 2009 Column Refuting Councilman Delucia's Column Critiquing Wetlands Law

Guest Column: Wetlands proposal is sound

If you read Peter DeLucia’s column in The Ledger last week, you might come away with serious misunderstandings about the town wetlands law and proposed revisions to it. I believe it is important to point out the deficiencies in that column, that we might proceed with discussions on a sound footing and pass the proposed administrative upgrades that will save homeowners time and money while continuing to protect out water supply and home values.

First off, we should note that the current iteration of the code has stood up to four years of exhaustive and aggressive (and expensive) challenges in court. While there has been a good deal of press about these suits, the day-to-day reality is that those tasked with applying the law — the Planning Board and the wetlands inspector — have found the law to be quite functional, and it has achieved its central purpose. While there is always room for tweaking, the Town Board member’s cry of “unfair” is at minimum an unfortunate rhetorical choice.

Mr. DeLucia makes much of the fines, but in fact the intent of the code is to achieve compliance and protect the water supply, not to punish. Larger fines may be assessed when the violation is deemed “willful.” There have been two such cases in the past few years. The average fine for all others during the same period is $194. He supports his case for reducing fine levels by comparing Lewisboro’s maximum fine with Bedford’s minimum. Such jarring logical misadventures cannot be a useful contribution to the dialog.

Mr. DeLucia contends that the drafters of the proposed modifications did damage to the existing code by removing the wetlands map, though he is fully aware that the town has no wetlands map, and never did. At the meeting where the Town Board reviewed the draft modifications, respected neighbor Dean Travalino helped reconstruct the history. In its earlier version, the code indeed called for reference to a town wetlands map, but such a map was never prepared. The folks who brought us the existing code, apparently recognizing this, removed the references, except they missed one appearance of the term — in the definitions. The code never actually applies the defined term, so it is misleading to say it has been removed and the drafters of the proposed modifications should not be accused of doing something they did not do, and could not have done.

Wetland maps are not the panacea that Mr. DeLucia’s column makes them out to be. In every case where they are made available, they are provided as macro guidelines only, and site-specific determinations are always made by a trained wetland biologist. Developing townwide wetlands maps would be an extremely expensive project, would need constant updating, and would not provide the definitive demarcation that he promises to readers.

Mr. DeLucia devotes much effort to advocating that only wetlands of some minimum size be subject to regulation. While it is not obvious to me that we can know what size wetlands we can write off without putting our water supply at risk, the more immediate problem is that the package of modifications prepared for us was intended to bring time and cost savings to homeowners quickly while deferring complex issues that would delay enactment or perhaps even threaten it altogether. Setting a size for wetlands is clearly one of those complex issues since it requires expert technical input and there is a good likelihood that opinions may diverge. Again, Mr. DeLucia is well aware of this background.

The use of the term “window dressing” to describe a set of sensible updates to the wetland code prepared by dedicated volunteers does not establish a good environment for working through this task. I hope we can move these useful changes through the legislative process quickly so that homeowners may enjoy the benefits.


... and here is Councilman Delucia's original column; does he really want to open this up again, encouraging frivolous suits that will hurt the town?:

Guest Column: Lewisboro needs a fair wetlands law

I appreciate the hard work put in by the supervisor’s task force in drafting proposed amendments to the town’s current wetland and watercourse code. Their goals, to make interpretation, compliance, and administration easier and to reduce expenses for homeowners, are those that I have been strongly advocating since first being elected four years ago.

However, after a review of the proposed revisions, it is clear that the more critically needed changes have not been included, and some of the proposed changes might actually be counterproductive.

For example, the current revisions remove the requirement that the town maintain a wetlands map. The town has never had more mapping capabilities than it has today. Additionally, the County Planning Department maintains wetland maps. Getting rid of the map requirement may save the town some money, but it certainly will not save homeowners any expenses. As with the state law and neighboring towns, the map serves as fair notice to homeowners of the presence of wetlands.

Doing away with the requirement that the town maintain a wetlands map is like doing away with the requirement to post speed limit signs on our highways. This is a fairness issue. How does a driver know he or she is speeding without a speed limit sign? How does a homeowner know that he or she is near wetlands without a map?

Generally, wetlands that don’t appear on a map are small, new, and often difficult to define, and usually artificially created by road runoff and other outside causes. Is it fair to then assess a fine for an unintentional violation? Lack of adequate notice is the reason that the Department of Environmental Conservation does not fine first offenders for inadvertent violations on wetlands that are not mapped, though they can be made to pay the cost of remediation.

Despite the revisions, the fines remain excessive. Drunk driving in New York carries a fine of $500, yet a first time wetlands violator can be subject to multiple fines of up to $7,500 each. In Bedford, the fines start at $250. While our current Planning Board has been fair in the administration of the law, the ordinance must be written to work no matter who is enforcing it. I would like to see a sliding scale of violations — nominal if the wetlands are not mapped and increasing after the first offense.

In addition, I remain uncomfortable with having planners, often already involved in the applicant’s permit application, act as a “wetlands court.” This is unfair both to the members of the board who must sit in judgment of their neighbors and to the applicants who deserve a hearing by an independent body. It is also contrary to my experience in hearings and enforcement at the county level, where we use independent hearing examiners to adjudicate health code violations.

Another concern is that under state law the “activities of farmers and other landowners” are exempt from local wetlands laws. Yet the new proposal contains a definition for “agriculture activities,” which would end this exemption for backyard farmers and horse owners. By contradicting the state law, this could render our entire local law invalid.

Also, the current proposal retains the controversial “clearance form,” which requires the wetlands inspector to come out and look at every project no matter how minor. This costs the town money by duplicating the efforts of the building department, and is an unreasonable intrusion on homeowners’ privacy.

Finally, if we intend to pass a law that increases protection for homeowners, provides certainty, and saves unwarranted expense, there needs to be a defined minimum size wetland area where the buffer regulations don’t apply. The state only regulates wetlands 12 acres or larger. In Pound Ridge, a watershed area and the only other local town with a 150-foot buffer, wetlands of less than one-quarter acre are exempt. Our local stormwater ordinance exempts area disturbances of fewer than 5,000 feet. Otherwise, we are back to the same illogical situation where a homeowner living on one acre with a small, seasonally wet depression three feet in diameter would be subject to an 150-foot buffer extending completely around this tiny “wetland” and effectively prohibited from doing anything on his or her property without a visit from the wetlands inspector and most likely incurring fees and other consulting costs.

I share the belief that the sooner the code is amended the better. However, without careful consideration of the changes outlined above, acting in haste will, at best, be just “window dressing” and more likely result in a further setback for the rights of Lewisboro homeowners.