Sep 19, 2009

8/20/09 Letter to Editor Re TB Votes Down Smart Grid

Last Thursday, the Pound Ridge Town Board voted to participate in a grant application under one of the richest of the economic recovery program initiatives. They join 8 other Northern Westchester towns in this effort to obtain funds to enable their residents and the municipal government to invest and earn revenue in the new "green" economy on the Fed's nickel. If/when the grant is won, if a town deems the arrangements not in their interest, they can still opt out. After the program is launched, the town and residents are under no obligation to utilize the grant funds to purchase Smart-grid-enabled appliances or invest in other income-generating electrical control facilities. After purchasing Smart grid enabled items with federal support, there is no obligation to participate in the electric grid "calls”. And then finally, if they do offer to “shed load” on call, the risk that the commitment is not met is taken on by a third party "aggregator”. On the same evening that Pound Ridge became the 9th town to join in, Lewisboro voted against participation - for the second time. Lewisboro is the only town to bring this simple, risk-free resolution to a vote, and vote it down. My colleagues offered an agitated avalanche of reasons, mostly around the risk theme, why they would not join Supervisor Ed Brancati and myself in voting to make this program available to the town. I found these totally at odds with reality. Perhaps they will have more success explaining to the public.

7/30/09 Letter to Editor re Recycling Center

[Printed as Guest Column] I suspect that there will be a number of letters complaining about the shutting down of regular operations at the recycling center. To some extent, I don't blame anyone for wanting to vent on this one; it certainly sounds bad. Lewisboro's recycling rate ranked near the bottom of the pile in statistics recently released by the County, so on its face, this would seem to be the wrong move at the wrong time. I believe however that this austerity move, just one of many large and small made in an effort to close the budget gap, could actually serve as the proverbial “kick in the pants” to push Lewisboro to the next level in sustainable waste management. A couple of weeks ago, 20-30 people from towns around the county gathered in Somers to hear Lewisboro’s Neil Cutler give an overview of options and best practices for managing and reducing the amount of material we send to landfills. Discussion followed, and the group intends to work on common approaches such as shared facilities and negotiating with carters for enhanced pickup options. I personally think that the key to increasing recycling rates is to expand the types of material we can put out on the curb and we will need the carters’ help with this. My carter only takes plastics 1 and 2 yet in some area towns they are already accepting 1-6. Maybe there could be periodic pickup of fluorescent bulbs or e-waste. Certainly mixed paper represents a large volume of the material going into our regular garbage and this could be recovered as well. The Lewisboro recycling center has been a great asset, but it has been taking two categories of material only – scrap metal and co-mingled glass and plastics. The latter is now taken by all carters, so in actuality, the only unique service we offered was the scrap metal. We are planning on opening up on a quarterly basis for this. We don’t know how it will all shake out exactly, but I feel certain that we will find ways to make it easier for residents to do the right thing with their waste.

3/26/09 Ledger Letter re Library Mailing

The library’s “Building Project Update” mailing was a welcome addition to a dialog which should afford Lewisboro residents a better chance to inform themselves about the plan to move the Library to the Town Park. My 250 words permits a only limited response here. The mailing states that the 20 plus year-old master plan is a policy statement only, a set of guidelines. The implication, not fully expressed, is that the principles and findings therein are no longer applicable, or, somehow inappropriate in this situation. Preserving the hamlets is one of the key themes of the MP, and removing the library from Main St. South Salem is not consistent with that. The proponents of the move to the park may feel that the benefits they cite outweigh this negative impact, but it remains a negative impact by any reasonable standard, not at all diminished by the fact that the Master Plan is a plan, and not legislation.

A late nineties survey is declared to have defined the needs of the community. I hope the library will post the questions and response summaries on the library website to help us understand the basis for the project scope. These days, it is a rare project which is not obliged to submit itself to the realities of compromise. A series of discrete questions (e.g., “is the children’s area adequate?”) may yield an attractive wish list, but designing a project which optimally balances these with un-surveyed factors, budgets and current reality is another thing.

Feb 13, 2009

2/12/2009 Letter re Library Project Worksession

I want to thank my colleagues on the Town Board, the Library Board and other participants for a good exchange last week in our work session on the library project. The thing that really stuck out for me was that, as much as it has been portrayed as being the best solution for the project, there was a marked lack of enthusiasm from the great majority of participants for the plan to move to the Town Park. The majority of the Board expressed the sense that keeping the library in the hamlet was the better option, yet ultimately voted 4-1 in favor of authorizing our engineering consultant to proceed with examination of the latest proposed site for septic, water and other details. Perhaps, understandably, this reflects a desire to be sensitive to the hard work done over the last decade, but we should be basing our decision on the larger picture; this plan fails to fulfill one of the key elements of the town's Master Plan - the preservation and enhancement our hamlets.

I'll say it again: if the library is to go anywhere, the only place that makes sense is at the heart of Cross River, as part of a larger effort to make that area realize its potential as a livable, functional hamlet, and a Town Center that Lewisboro never had. But, since a suitable plot and that larger plan are nowhere in sight, the best option now is to stay put. Design the project around the funding that is available now, put a second story on the front of the building, maybe do without the “multipurpose room,” and go forward – now.

Jan 2, 2009

12/31/08 Letter to Editor Re Misleading

I don't for a moment think it was some conscious effort to create a ruckus where there wasn't, but anybody reading the "Narrowly Passes" headline and browsing the story would have to come to the conclusion that there were two diametrically opposed sides in the discussions. In reality, there was plenty of noise, but no disagreement on anything material. There will no doubt be opportunities to report on actual disagreement going forward. The Ledger deserved this poke.

Ledger Article was Misleading

Consciously or un, December 24th's “Town Budget Narrowly Passes” article was misleading, in that it left out any facts that would not support its narrow narrative. The headline and text seem to suggest that there is one faction fighting against rising costs while another treats these with indifference. For example, the article credits Mr. Delucia with a comment about moving to centralized purchasing, but if you check the minutes, you will find the first comment about this to have been made by Mr. Brancati. I am quoted once in the article, saying that I did “not want to hack away and risk hurting town programs”. Left out was the fact that I said we should continue to work on operation costs going forward into the new year, but that cutting more at this time without any additional facts would not be wise. Also left out, any reference to the substantial savings achieved by restructurings to our benefit packages initiated by the supervisor.

Both Mr Brancati and myself offered to continue with the line-item review if our colleagues wanted to do so, but our colleagues did not take us up on this. Lets face it, the two nay votes by my colleagues were political freebies – up or down, the budget would be unchanged. Voting no allowed them to lay claim to the populist fiscal position without any real downside. I do not begrudge them a bit of political posturing, but the Ledger should not be abetting this. Consciously or un.

and in response, this "Editor's note:

Although the article did not specifically mention Mr. Welsh when talking about reducing operation costs next year, it say that all of the board members agreed to review the town's organization next year to save money.

Noted, but this reference to "all the board members" does not alter the overall message in any significant way.

Dec 29, 2008

Statement re library at 12/4 Town Board work session

It is now two years since the deal was made to move the library to the Park and we don't yet have a final resolution for the site location, let alone be anywhere close to breaking ground.

The proposed move would have tremendous impacts on the town and certainly on the hamlet of South Salem, and yet there has been no attempt to solicit public comment.

Though the library is operated as an independent entity, the majority of the funding of course comes from town taxes. Significant funds have already been spent. The details of the financial arrangements for the project have been reported to some extent I believe, but are not readily available for the public to review on either the town or library websites as far as I can see. As I understand those, the town has committed to cover some portion of construction overruns. We need to know the magnitude of our exposure, particularly in today's climate.

There is, and always has been, a less costly alternative to the Town Park - expansion at the original site. That alternative was shelved not because of irreconcilable technical obstacles, but due to human factors. It is quite possible that the passage of time may have mitigated those factors and this effective option may be pursued.

We need to know more, but from what I do know, it seems clear to me that keeping the library in South Salem hamlet is the most cost effective path to expansion. Moving it to the park will be costly and is contrary to the hamlet-centered planning philosophy set out in the town Master Plan and to the great preponderance of opinion on modern town planning.

I believe the Town Board therefore has a duty to take up discussion of the current status of the project, review the arrangements and financials, and facilitate a forum to collect resident input, and so I propose that these things be put on the agenda.

12/4/08 Letter to the Editor re AP Fields Commentaries

Certain recent commentaries and letters have asserted that Supervisor Brancati was the "chief advocate" for the Legacy Fund/A.P. Farms proposal, and that he reversed himself by voting "no." In fact, Mr. Brancati worked hard to see that the case for this proposal got a fair airing. To make that happen required that he work with the County at various levels to make sure that preconditions for making the offer were attainable. Only by doing this would we even have had a chance to go through the process and see whether the project might be a net benefit to the town. Would our residents have been satisfied with anything less than such a good faith effort? This was not a case of "good guys" vs. "bad guys" -- it was an example of the supervisor doing his job by exploring all the options and putting them on the table. Mr. Brancati remained objective and uncommitted up until the vote. His statements were always measured, and he made it clear that the decision should be made on merits only. This is not "spin" -- it's all there in the public record.

On the whole, I have found the atmosphere on the town board this past year to be civil and productive. I do not expect us all to agree on everything. Nor do I expect critics to “go easy” on us -- but I do expect their comments to be reality-based, and well intentioned. That has not been the case thus far. I am hopeful that well-meaning colleagues and neighbors will direct the focus back to sensible and objective analysis, constructive ideas and cheers for the many doing the good and hard work.